Do you want to know which are the best restaurants in Key Largo? Here’s a list of restaurants you must try while you’re here!
When you’re driving from Miami to Key West, don’t forget to stop at one of the best Key Largo restaurants to fuel your journey! You would really be missing out if you simply drive through town. The Upper Keys have so much to offer, yet so many people only drive through them.
Located off the coast of Florida, the Upper Keys consist of Islamorada, Tavenier, Plantation Key, Windley Key, Upper Matecumbe Key, Tea Table Key, Lignumvitae, and of course the oldest key, Key Largo.
As the first of the Florida Keys, Key Largo is the start of the trip for most visitors! Explore John Pennekamp State Park’s hiking trails and snorkeling opportunities or take the glass bottom boat to Molasses Reef to work up an appetite before eating. There’s plenty to do on Key Largo!
Freshly caught seafood is a specialty of most best restaurants in Key Largo, FL. There are a lot of great places to eat in Key largo, from dockside restaurants to local favorites! Despite this, you can enjoy Thai food, Pizza, Italian, subs, breakfast or brunch spots, as well as Mexican cuisine, if you’re not into seafood.
Before we get into restaurants, let’s talk about the top dishes you definitely need to try at any of these restaurants in Key Largo! These are all Florida Keys classics for a reason.
Stone Crab: Stone crab is a type of crab found in the Atlantic Ocean, and is considered a delicacy. It is usually served with drawn butter for dipping.
Conch Fritters: Conch is a type of shellfish that is used in many dishes in the Florida Keys. Conch fritters are battered and fried chunks of conch meat and are often served with a dipping sauce.
Key Lime Pie: Key lime pie is a dessert made with key lime juice, eggs, and sweetened condensed milk. It is usually served with whipped cream or ice cream on top. If you’re in the Keys, you definitely need to try Key Lime Pie: it’s literally required!
Conch Chowder: Conch chowder is a soup made with conch meat, potatoes, onions, and spices. It is often served with crackers or bread on the side.
Now that you know what to order let’s get into the best restaurants in Key Largo!
21. Key Largo Conch House
The Key Largo Conch House is one of the family-owned and operated Key Largo Restaurants. It is worth noting the restaurant is closed on Thursdays but open From 8 am to 9 or 10 pm every other day!
They serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner inside or outside on the garden veranda, complete with a house parrot.
If looking for one of the best breakfasts in Key Largo stop here for their signature Eggs Benedicts. Specifically, try the cracked conch Benedict topped with lobster and conch ceviche if you love seafood.
For dinner, start off with the Conch House sampler with conch fritters, coconut shrimp, cracked conch, and conch ceviche. Entrees include fresh catch of local caught fillets, either grilled, fried, or blackened. The locally caught hogfish is amazing, as are the conch house tacos.
Not to worry: for the vegetarians, they serve a veggie curry and even have a vegan option.
This is definitely one of the overall best restaurants in Key Largo. We recommend starting here if you’re spending a few days on this Key!
Address: 100211 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
20. Sal Ballyhoo’s
Sitting in a little hut in Key Largo, Ballyhoo’s is one of the more casual seafood restaurants in Key Largo. But the food is really yummy – this place is one of the famous Key Largo restaurants for a reason!
Start off with any of the super fresh and delicious fried fish appetizers. The conch chowder is also delicious and hearty. As for entrees, they have several pasta dishes as well as fresh seafood options like mahi mahi, shrimp, and lobster.
Sal Ballyhoo’s has a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. The space features a small rustic garden and a nautical theme.
Vegetarian and vegan options are also available. Additionally, there are always plenty of stone crabs available for guests to dine on – we highly recommend!
This is one of the best restaurants in Key Largo if you want to stop in for a quick, cute lunch.
Address: 97860 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo
19. Lazy Lobster Seafood Restaurant
Lazy Lobster is one of the top seafood restaurants in Key Largo, open from 11 am to 10 pm. You can eat inside or out on their cute little tiki patio near the marina. The restaurant is family-friendly and is a great place for just about everyone.
This is one of the first restaurants in the Florida Keys I ever visited. We stopped off on our drive down to Key West and wow was the atmosphere awesome. We immediately met two fishermen who gave us lots of tips and bought us beers. You’ll know you’re in the Keys at Lazy Lobster!
Appetizers include fresh oysters, conch fritters, and cerviche. For something different try the tuna poke nachos. As for entrees, they have several seafood pasta dishes as well as local Florida Keys favorites like blackened Mahi Mahi and yellowtail snapper. The portions are large, so come hungry!
Address: 102770 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
18. Buzzard’s Roost
There are few better places to eat in Key Largo than Buzzard’s Roost. If you’ve had your fill of one of the best beaches, come here for a bite to eat.
It’s located along the beautiful Garden Cove Marina. The tropical setting complete with tiki bar decor creates a paradise-like atmosphere.
With a tiki bar theme outside and a dining room decked out in warm woods inside, it wraps up the tropical setting right on the water in the Garden Cove Marina. The seafood is always insanely fresh!
There is a wide variety of delicious seafood and meat dishes to enjoy. There is an extensive menu to choose from. While it can get busy on the weekends, this place offers an amazing brunch in the morning, a happy hour for drinks in the evening, and live music at night.
Overall, Buzzard’s Roost is one of the most fun restaurants in Key Largo and is a great place to check out if you’re actually staying on the island.
Address: 21 Garden Cove Dr, Key Largo
17. Hobo’s Cafe
In addition to being one of Key Largo’s most authentic restaurants, Hobo’s Cafe is located at mile marker 101, making it a great place to stop in for a vite. They serve both lunch and dinner.
Hobo’s Caribbean Jerked Chicken salad or Hobo Wedge are some of the salads that guests can choose. Among the Hobo’s specialties are the ceviche of tender conch, award-winning wings, wahoo fish dip, island seafood sampler with Mahi fingers, conch fritters, and wahoo fish dip.
Sandwiches with homemade key lime butter sauce are also popular with chicken, lobster, or fish. Among their burger choices are the Greek Isles Lamb or the Sloppy Hobo Burger, and a MM 101 sandwich with creamed spinach and artichokes on focaccia bread.
Address: 101691 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
16. Mrs. Mac’s Kitchen
In Key Largo, Mrs. Mac’s is a long-standing local legend. Established in 1976, it has become one of the favorite hometown cafes. An air of coolness, kitschy charm, and a certain novelty permeates this place.
The restaurant serves American and Caribbean food. You can’t go wrong with the Homemade Chilli, Crab Cakes, or Conch Chowder at this restaurant. Our recommendation is to try to save some room for dessert. The Key Lime Pie is incredible!
Mrs. Mac’s is one of the defining Key Largo restaurants, and it is a must-visit when you’re in town, especially if you want to get a taste of the local atmosphere.
Address: 99020 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
15. Hideout Key Largo
This classic diner serves up the best of Southern American breakfasts and lunches. This is the best spot if you’re looking for large portions, a good price, and comfort foods. The space is inviting, with plenty of unique personality, and a cute outdoor deck to dine al fresco. It’s also dog friendly.
If you’re looking for breakfast, the pancakes are some of the best around.
Overall, Hideout Key Largo is a great spot for a casual meal. The food is delicious and the prices are fair. Plus, the atmosphere can’t be beat!
Address: 47 Shoreland Dr, Key Largo
14. C&C Wood Fire Eats
C&C Wood Fire Eats is a great choice if you’re looking for a romantic dinner. The restaurant serves wood-fired pizzas and steaks.
They have a wide selection of pizzas, including the classic Margherita, the Meat Lovers, and the White Pizza. For steaks, they have options like the Ribeye, the New York Strip, and the Filet Mignon.
If you’re looking for a side, the roasted Brussels sprouts are a great choice. The restaurant also has an extensive wine list.
C&C Wood Fire Eats is the perfect spot for a date night. The food is amazing and the atmosphere is very romantic and woodsy inside – definitely different from the typical Key Largo restaurant/bar shacks.
Address: Northbound At Flashing Yellow Light, 99201 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Sundowners is one of Key Largo’s most popular bars. It’s located right on the water, so you can enjoy beautiful views while sipping on a cocktail.
The bar has a great happy hour, and the drinks are all reasonably priced. The bartenders are also very friendly.
If you’re looking for a place to relax and enjoy a few drinks, Sundowners is the perfect spot. The atmosphere is casual and laid-back, and the views are simply incredible. This is definitely the place to be for sunset so get here early!
Address: 103900 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
This family-run restaurant has been serving up Italian classics in Key Largo since 1978. The restaurant is small with a cozy atmosphere. They have an extensive menu with something for everyone.
Some of the popular dishes include the Chicken Parmesan, the Veal Marsala, and the Shrimp Fra Diavolo. The pasta is all homemade and the sauce is delicious. The Tiramisu is a must-try for dessert.
If you’re looking for a great Italian meal, DiGiorgio’s is the spot. The food is fantastic, and the family-run atmosphere makes it all the cozier and inviting.
Address: 99530 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo
11. Sol By The Sea
Sol by the Sea is a great choice for lunch or dinner. The Key Largo restaurant has a beautiful patio with views of the water. They serve both American and Caribbean cuisine.
This Key Largo restaurant is located at one of the best resorts on the island so it’s definitely on the fancier side! Plus, the views are just gorgeous.
Some of the popular dishes include the Jerk Chicken, the Coconut Shrimp, and the Mahi Mahi. The cocktails are also very good – definitely try the Sol Sunrise.
If you’re looking for a nice dinner with beautiful views, Sol by the Sea is a great option. The food is delicious, and the atmosphere is perfect – it’s definitely one of the more elegant restaurants in Key Largo.
10. Doc’s Diner
Doc’s Diner is a great choice for breakfast or lunch. The food is delicious and the prices are reasonable. Plus, the diner has a fun 1950s theme.
The menu features all of your classic American favorites like burgers, fries, and milkshakes. The chicken-fried steak is also very popular.
If you’re looking for a great meal at a reasonable price, Doc’s Diner is the spot. The food is delicious and the atmosphere is fun and nostalgic. Plus, it’s family-owned!
Address: 99696 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
9. Alabama Jack’s
Alabama Jack’s is a popular spot for both locals and tourists. The restaurant is located right on the water (on top of two barges among the mangroves), so you can enjoy beautiful views while enjoying your meal. You literally feel like you’re one with the swamp, making this one of the most authentic restaurants in Key Largo.
The menu features both American and Caribbean cuisine. It has a “dive bar” vibe that’s really fun and feels very local.
The Conch Fritters, Steamed Shrimp, and various Fish Sandwiches are all really good. The fish is insanely fresh!
We recommend coming to this Key Largo restaurant on the weekends for live music. It’s definitely a fun local hangout.
Address: 58000 Card Sound Rd, Key Largo, FL 33030
8. Skipper’s Dockside
Skipper’s Dockside is a great choice for lunch or dinner. The restaurant is located right on the water, so you can enjoy beautiful views while enjoying your meal.
The menu features both American and Caribbean cuisine. Some of the popular dishes include the jerk chicken, the conch fritters, and the Mahi Mahi.
The cocktails are also very good – definitely try the rum punch. If you’re looking for a place to relax and enjoy a meal with a view, Skipper’s Dockside is the perfect spot.
Address: 528 Caribbean Dr, Key Largo, FL 33037
Calusa is one of the trendier restaurants in Key Largo, but it’s quickly become a local favorite. The restaurant is located in Baker’s Cay Resort, so you can enjoy beautiful water views while dining. It’s gorgeous during sunset!
The menu features American cuisine with a hint of Creole and Caribbean flavors and a focus on fresh, locally caught seafood.
Some of the popular dishes include the Jumbo Lump Crab Cake, the Grouper Sandwich, and the Shrimp Po’boy. The cocktails are also very good – definitely try the Key Lime Pie Martini.
This is a great choice for dinner if you’re looking for something slightly upscale but still casual. The food is delicious, and the atmosphere is perfect for a date night or a night out with friends. Make sure to get here early for sunset!
6. Jimmy Johnson’s Big Chill
Jimmy Johnson’s Big Chill in Key Largo serves American food with some of the best beach views in the area. It is both a great restaurant and a great entertainment venue. There is also a separate tiki bar on the patio, which overlooks the shimmering waters of Florida Bay.
In addition to their large menus, which include pizza, burgers, sandwiches, a raw bar, and more, they offer a great happy hour. All of the seafood is incredibly fresh – most of it is locally caught.
This is one of the most varied restaurants in Key Largo – it has something for everyone. It definitely attracts a lot of tourists for a reason.
Address: 104000 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
5. Harriette’s Restaurant
Harriette’s Restaurant is a Key Largo institution. It’s been around for decades, and it’s one of the most popular restaurants in town.
The menu features American cuisine with a focus on fresh seafood. Some of the popular dishes include the Crab Cakes and the Grouper Sandwich.
This is a great choice for dinner if you’re looking for something classic and iconic. It’s just located in a small shack off the road but wow is Harriette’s worth the trip. The food is delicious, and the atmosphere is perfect for a night out with friends or family.
Address: 95710 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
4. Snappers Waterfront Cafe
The Key Largo restaurant Snappers is one of the most popular oceanfront eateries in the Florida Keys. There are three bars, a weekly party, special events, and suites for guests available on-site.
This menu has something for everyone. Shareables such as cheeseburgers and Bacon Wrapped Scallops are legendary. It’s super fun to try out the “You Hook ‘Em, We Cook ‘Em” option here.
Address: 139 Seaside Ave, Key Largo, FL 33037
3. Mikes BBQ 101
At Mike’s BBQ 101, you’ll find some of the best brisket you’ve ever eaten. Small and red, the food truck by the side of the road has a lot of personality. They are known for their authentic barbecue, which always seems to impress.
Include the Mac and Cheese and the Cornbread in any order you choose. They also offer a variety of savory and sweet sauces, so you can dress up your perfectly smoked meat however you like it.
This is the perfect place to stop for lunch if you’re in the mood for some good old-fashioned barbecue. It’s so good that even locals make the trip out here!
Address: 101900 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
2. Blackwater Siren
Overlooking the ocean, this pub serves local comfort food. The atmosphere is casual and rustic. Both the indoor and outdoor seating have a beachside feel. The menu offers familiar dishes with an artistic twist. We recommend the Coconut Onion Rings and Smoked Fish Dip.
If you’d rather not have more seafood, there are lots of pasta, sandwich, and burger options, too. This is one of the best restaurants in Key Largo for all types of eaters. Plus, the views of the water are beautiful and the atmosphere is a lot of fun!
Address: 107690 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
1. The Fish House
The Fish House serves dock-to-table fare and is a staple of the foodie scene in the Upper Keys. Relaxed and authentic, it perfectly captures Florida’s laid-back culture. Lights cover the ceiling, and framed photographs adorn the walls, giving the space a festive, nautical feel.
The restaurant specializes in conch cooking, with many signature chowders and fresh fish dishes that are either smoked, steamed, or sauteed. Each day’s catch is determined by the conditions and availability of the local commercial fishermen, depending on the season. In addition to this, there’s an on-site market that makes shopping for the perfect souvenir a breeze. As well as craft beer and specialty cocktails, the bar offers craft cocktails.
Address: 102401 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo
Key Largo is home to some incredible restaurants. Whether you’re looking for a casual meal or a romantic dinner, there’s something for everyone. Be sure to check out Mrs. Mac’s, Hideout Key Largo, Hobo’s Cafe, C&C Wood Fire Eats, DiGiorgio’s, and Sundowners during your stay.